
Movie review
February 27, 2020 · 102 min · M · Mystery · Adventure · Drama
Phryne Fisher is a wealthy Australian adventurer and private detective who travels through 1920s Jerusalem, London, and the Negev desert. She frees Shirin, a young Bedouin girl held in prison, and promises to learn who killed Shirin’s family. Phryne and Detective Inspector Jack Robinson follow a trail of emeralds, wartime secrets, a railway deal, and an ancient tomb linked to Alexander the Great. The film mixes mystery, romance, gun fights, plane stunts, desert danger, and playful humor.
The film makes Phryne the main solver, fighter, pilot, and rescuer, while Jack works beside her as a helper and love interest. Phryne protects a young Bedouin girl and brings a hidden massacre and stolen treasure to light. The story also shows British officials and soldiers hiding wrongdoing and treating local people as obstacles. These ideas are clear and recurring, but the film presents them through a fast, old-fashioned adventure instead of long political speeches.
Community feedback
Was our 56% Woke rating accurate?
Breakdown
These are the editorial factors and ratings behind our score for Miss Fisher and the Crypt of Tears.
Woke representation / casting
Phryne is a middle-aged woman at the center of a large action and mystery story. She is the strongest problem solver on screen, while Jack is often the helper and love interest. Interviews and reviews also frame the lead as important because women of her age rarely get this kind of role. The Arab characters fit the 1920s Palestine setting and plot, so they do not create a clear casting mismatch.
40%
Woke political dialogue
Shirin says her family was murdered and that she wants justice. Officials call her a possible agitator and worry about anti-British propaganda. Characters discuss British control, a railway deal, and the looting of a Bedouin tribe. These lines recur around the mystery, but the film spends more time on clues, fights, and romance than on political speeches.
31%
Identity-driven story themes
Phryne repeatedly leads the action, rescues Shirin, flies the plane, fights attackers, and solves the case. Jack helps her, but the film makes him her helper and love interest. Phryne's sexual freedom and refusal to become a policeman's wife are treated as strengths. The story also seeks justice for a young Bedouin survivor and blames British power for hiding the truth. These ideas shape the main adventure, even though the film stays playful.
58%
Western institutional / cultural critique
British military authorities imprison Shirin, dismiss her account, and say the village attack was already investigated. British soldiers and officials connect the stolen jewels to a railway deal and try to keep the scandal quiet. The film presents this abuse of power as a past injustice in its adventure plot. It does not turn the issue into a broad modern attack on Western culture or religion.
32%
Woke character or canon changes
Not relevant. The film continues the established Phryne Fisher and Jack Robinson characters in a new story. It does not change a known character's race, gender, sexuality, or hero role.
0%
Anti-woke backlash and complaints
Not present. The supplied X pass found no anti-woke complaints. Other public comments focused on pacing, plot, missing series characters, and romance rather than woke, DEI, or identity politics.
0%
Creator track record context
The stored profiles give Deb Cox and Fiona Eagger strong records of female-led stories, women’s agency, and gender representation work. Title interviews describe the film as a social justice story about British rule in Palestine and a young Palestinian woman, while also saying the film does not push politics. Tony Tilse has no known activist profile, and Lucy Maclaren, Ann Robinson, and Aria Harrison have mild or limited signals in the stored profiles. The overall creator context is therefore moderate rather than dominant.
43%
Production