Movie review
March 23, 2023 · 134 min · PG-13 · Fantasy · Comedy · Adventure
Edgin is a smooth-talking bard who lost his wife and got locked up after a bad heist. With his barbarian friend Holga, he breaks out of prison to win back his daughter and clear his name. They gather a messy team for a big fantasy heist in a magic world full of monsters, spells, and double-crosses. The tone is light, funny, and full of adventure.
The film is mainly a fun heist and friendship story. Viewers will still notice a diverse main team and strong women who do a lot of the fighting, while some male heroes act more like comic helpers than classic tough leads. Holga is a powerhouse fighter, Doric is a capable druid who also fights loggers in her forest, and Xenk is a near-perfect heroic paladin. Directors said they like “emasculating” male leads for laughs, not as a politics speech, but that choice is easy to see on screen. A few right-leaning writers and posts called the casting and girl-power action “woke.” Many other viewers said it felt like plain fun. The story does not push heavy modern identity lectures.
Community feedback
Was our 42% Woke rating accurate?
Breakdown
These are the editorial factors and ratings behind our score for Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves.
Woke representation / casting
Clear diverse main cast: Latina barbarian co-lead Holga, black sorcerer Simon, and black paladin Xenk as a highly skilled hero. Women often lead fights. Fantasy setting softens race mismatch claims, but the pattern of capable diverse heroes is easy to notice. Not pure story-blind casting only.
40%
Woke political dialogue
Almost no modern activist speeches. Lines cover heists, magic, jokes, and family. Xenk makes the group swear to share loot with regular people. That is mild “help the poor,” not race, gender, or identity lectures.
5%
Identity-driven story themes
Core themes are friendship, betrayal, and saving a child. Doric was abandoned as a tiefling outsider and fights forest logging with her enclave. Light found-family notes. No major race, gender, or queer identity plot is the main engine of the film. Gender comedy emphasizing capable women and less heroic men.
35%
Western institutional / cultural critique
Villains are a crooked lord and evil wizards—classic fantasy bad guys, not modern “systemic” targets. Comedy often puts women in the fight and men in the rear, which softens traditional male hero roles. That is a mild gender-role poke, not a full attack on Western faith, family, or culture.
20%
Woke character or canon changes
Not relevant. Main heroes are new characters. No well-known book hero is race- or gender-swapped for identity politics.
0%
Anti-woke backlash and complaints
Right-leaning outlets and posts hit the film for diversity casting, girl-power fights, and directors admitting they like emasculating male leads. Others on that side said it was not woke. Complaints exist and are on-theme, but they were not the main public story.
32%
Creator track record context
Key writers and directors have low stored scores and no strong activist record. Some producers show mild corporate DEI or liberal politics; casting leans more representation-focused. Overall crew context is light support, not a hard activist team.
18%
Production
Movie · 2019
As the gang return to Jumanji to rescue one of their own, they discover that nothing is as they expect. The players will have to brave parts unknown and unexplored in order to…
Movie · 2021
When single mom Callie and her two kids Trevor and Phoebe arrive in a small Oklahoma town, they begin to discover their connection to the original Ghostbusters and the secret…
Movie · 2020
Seven years since the Monsterpocalypse began, Joel Dawson has been living underground in order to survive. But after reconnecting over radio with his high school girlfriend Aimee…
Movie · 2023
Following the sudden death of his mother, a mild-mannered but anxiety-ridden man confronts his darkest fears as he embarks on an epic odyssey back home.
Movie · 2023
Paul and Sophie, interns at a mysterious London firm, become steadily aware their employers Humphrey and Dennis are anything but conventional – they are disrupting the world of…
Movie · 2026
A group of college students go downstairs to their dorm lobby to get a delivery pizza. There's only one issue: They're insanely high on a homemade drug, turning their simple…
Movie · 2023
Hapless family man Paul Matthews finds his life turned upside down when millions of strangers suddenly start seeing him in their dreams.
Movie · 2019
A boy is given the ability to become an adult superhero in times of need with a single magic word.
