Movie review
November 21, 2024 · 100 min · PG · Kids · Fantasy · Animation · Comedy · Adventure · Family
Moana journeys across the sea to find a lost island and break an ancient curse. She wants to bring her separated people back together. The movie has a strong focus on girl power, showing Moana as a highly competent leader and captain. It also features a young female prodigy who acts as the crew's chief builder and engineer.
Community feedback
Was our 30% Woke rating accurate?
Breakdown
These are the editorial factors and ratings behind our score for Moana 2.
Woke representation / casting
The cast is fully diverse, focusing on Polynesian culture and representation. The new crew features Loto, a young female prodigy who serves as a brilliant builder and engineer. This fits the common trope of highly competent young female experts in modern media. However, the diverse casting aligns naturally with the Pacific Island setting. There is no visible identity signaling or forced quotas that feel out of place in this world.
25%
Woke political dialogue
The script contains no political talking points, activist statements, or modern identity lectures. The characters speak in ways that fit the fantasy historical setting.
0%
Production
Identity-driven story themes
The story focuses on reclaiming cultural heritage and bringing together separated indigenous communities. While these themes of cultural unity and ancestral connection are prominent, they are treated as traditional folklore rather than modern activist sermons. The central theme of female leadership is present through Moana, but it represents standard Disney girl-power rather than heavy-handed feminist theory.
25%
Western institutional / cultural critique
There is no critique of Western institutions, capitalism, or traditional values. The conflict is a simple fantasy struggle against an ancient god who wants to keep people divided. It does not critique modern social norms or Western culture.
0%
Woke character or canon changes
Not present in this title.
0%
Anti-woke backlash and complaints
Backlash was very low. Some anti-woke commentators and family-focused outlets scrutinized the film due to Disney's recent track record. However, conservative and family-centric review sites ultimately rated the movie as a safe and clean option for kids. It avoided the major backlash faced by other recent Disney releases.
15%
Creator track record context
The creative team has a mixed track record. Prominent writers and producers like Jared Bush, Jennifer Lee, and Yvett Merino have heavily supported Disney's recent diversity mandates and progressive storytelling goals. Conversely, producer Dwayne Johnson has openly criticized preachy political lessons in Hollywood films, advocating for universal storytelling instead.
38%
Movie · 2024
A solitary cat, displaced by a great flood, finds refuge on a boat with various species and must navigate the challenges of adapting to a transformed world together.
Movie · 2019
It's been ten years since the dragons moved to the Hidden World, and even though Toothless doesn't live in New Berk anymore, Hiccup continues the holiday traditions he once shared…
Movie · 2023
While working underground to fix a water main, Brooklyn plumbers—and brothers—Mario and Luigi are transported down a mysterious pipe and wander into a magical new world.
Movie · 2019
A group of misfits encounter a young Yeti named Everest, and they set off to reunite the magical creature with his family on the mountain of his namesake.
Movie · 2024
Gromit’s concern that Wallace is becoming too dependent on his inventions proves justified, when Wallace invents a “smart” gnome that seems to develop a mind of its own.
Movie · 2026
Living on a rundown shipwreck, Mr. Fish one day discovers a hyperactive young sea dragon Pip – who had mistaken his home for a junkyard – pilfering his belongings.
Movie · 2023
After a migrating duck family alights on their pond with thrilling tales of far-flung places, the Mallard family embarks on a family road trip, from New England, to New York City…
Movie · 2020
After losing his wife seven years earlier, the eccentric Dr. John Dolittle, famed doctor and veterinarian of Queen Victoria’s England, hermits himself away behind the high walls…
