TV Show review
Review basis: 1 season · through May 31, 2019
May 31, 2019 · TV-MA · Ended
Woke Score
Lower is better
Review
When They See Us is a four-part Netflix miniseries that dramatizes the 1989 Central Park jogger case. Five Black and Latino teenagers from Harlem were arrested, interrogated without parents or lawyers, tried, and convicted of a brutal rape despite weak evidence. They served years in prison before exoneration in 2002 when the real attacker confessed. The series centers racial identity as the key reason authorities targeted the boys, with heavy focus on police coercion, prosecutorial choices, and media frenzy that treated young men of color as threats by default.
Breakdown
These are the editorial factors and ratings behind our score for When They See Us.
Woke representation / casting
Casting matches the real racial and ethnic backgrounds of the 1989 Harlem teens and other figures exactly, with no mismatches to the historical setting or story logic.
Woke political dialogue
Scenes include discussions of race and police treatment of minorities during interrogations and trials, but these stay tied to the dramatic events rather than modern activist speeches.
Identity-driven story themes
The entire premise revolves around how the boys' Black and Latino identities made them targets for arrest and conviction in a case lacking solid evidence.
Western institutional / cultural critique
The series presents the NYPD, prosecutors, and media as shaped by racial bias and rush to judgment against young men of color, using the 1989 case to illustrate broader systemic problems.
Woke character or canon changes
It dramatizes real people and events with some added dialogue and emphasis; former prosecutor Linda Fairstein publicly called her portrayal distorted and sued over it.
Anti-woke backlash and complaints
A minority of viewers called it one-sided political propaganda or agenda-driven, especially around portrayals of authorities and Trump; most debate centered on factual accuracy instead.
Creator track record context
Led by Ava DuVernay with multiple writers who repeatedly explore racial injustice and Black experiences in their own work.
Production
