Movie review
March 10, 2023 · 99 min · PG · Kids · Fantasy · Animation · Comedy · Adventure · Family
The Magician's Elephant is an animated family film about an orphan named Peter. Peter must complete three impossible tasks to win a magical elephant and find his long-lost sister. The movie shows prominent multicultural casting in its historic European setting. There are multiple interracial couples and diverse characters in positions of power. These casting choices are highly visible to viewers.
Community feedback
Was our 31% Woke rating accurate?
Breakdown
These are the editorial factors and ratings behind our score for The Magician's Elephant.
Woke representation / casting
The movie uses very diverse voice actors for a fantasy setting based on old Europe. Characters like Leo, the Countess, and the King are played by black and Asian actors. The movie also features interracial couples. These casting choices feel like modern identity representation rather than story necessity. There are no queer elements in this movie, which keeps the score from going higher.
37%
Woke political dialogue
The movie does not have any political dialogue. The characters talk about magic, hope, family, and completing tasks. There are no social justice lectures or modern political debates in the script.
0%
Identity-driven story themes
The story is a simple fairy tale about finding family, believing in hope, and helping a community. It does not focus on modern identity politics. It does not teach about systemic oppression or privilege.
0%
Western institutional / cultural critique
The movie has some typical fairy tale tropes about silly leaders, like the king and a funny police chief. Peter's guardian is a harsh retired soldier who lied to him. However, these are standard tropes about authority. They are not modern activist attacks on Western institutions or traditional family values. The local nuns and church are shown as kind.
3%
Woke character or canon changes
The movie makes the setting of the original book much more diverse. The book takes place in a historic European town. The movie changes many characters to have different ethnic backgrounds. These changes feel like they were made to fit modern representation rules.
25%
Anti-woke backlash and complaints
There were a few complaints on online forums about the casting. Some viewers felt the diverse cast and interracial couples felt forced for a historic European setting. However, there was no major public backlash or widespread political controversy.
25%
Creator track record context
Most of the directors, writers, and producers have a score of zero. They have no history of political activism or social justice work. Author Kate DiCamillo has a score of 20 for supporting progressive causes in children's books, and casting director Mary Hidalgo has a score of 11. This keeps the creator track record score very low.
11%
Production
Movie · 2024
Teenager Riley's mind headquarters is undergoing a sudden demolition to make room for something entirely unexpected: new Emotions!
Movie · 2018
Siblings Kate and Teddy try to prove Santa Claus is real, but when they accidentally cause his sleigh to crash, they have to save Christmas.
Movie · 2022
Puss in Boots discovers that his passion for adventure has taken its toll: He has burned through eight of his nine lives, leaving him with only one life left.
Movie · 2024
Gromit’s concern that Wallace is becoming too dependent on his inventions proves justified, when Wallace invents a “smart” gnome that seems to develop a mind of its own.
Movie · 2024
A boy with an active imagination faces his fears on an unforgettable journey through the night with his new friend: a giant, smiling creature named Dark.
Movie · 2017
When Chloe discovers that her new home's garden gnomes are not what they seem, she must decide between the pursuit of a desired high school life and taking up the fight against…
Movie · 2023
A magical meteor crash lands in Adventure City and gives the PAW Patrol pups superpowers, transforming them into The Mighty Pups.
Movie · 2019
A group of misfits encounter a young Yeti named Everest, and they set off to reunite the magical creature with his family on the mountain of his namesake.
