Supergirl is a gritty, space-western action film following a cynical and self-destructive Kara Zor-El who reluctantly joins forces with a young orphan named Ruthye on an interstellar quest for vengeance. The movie incorporates dark, mature themes by introducing a fabricated subplot where the main antagonists are an all-male society of space pirates who kidnap and traffic young girls as "brides." It heavily alters traditional superhero ethics and its source comic's message, culminating in the heroine executing the defeated villain rather than rising above revenge. These narrative choices, combined with the lead actress's promotional comments embracing queer readings and rejecting traditional gender expectations, triggered intense division and critical backlash.
Community feedback
Was our 59% Woke rating accurate?
Breakdown
These are the editorial factors and ratings behind our score for Supergirl.
Woke representation / casting
While the casting of a traditional white lead for Kara Zor-El and Eve Ridley as Ruthye fits the basic narrative, the film's creative direction heavily pushes a "messy, modern woman" archetype designed to defy traditional feminine representation.
20%
Woke political dialogue
Mostly action and revenge-focused. Includes minor gender-related lines such as a young girl questioning the "Supergirl" vs "Superwoman" naming convention and one scene where Ruthye practically instructs the macho Lobo character. These are light and isolated rather than extended activist speeches.
18%
Identity-driven story themes
The plot centers on a cynical female antihero who rejects romance, teamed with a young girl to dismantle an all-male sex-trafficking ring. The themes are heavily framed around female empowerment, sisterhood, and deconstructing traditional heroism, which Milly Alcock actively reinforced during press tours by claiming Kara "doesn't live inside the binary".
42%
Western institutional / cultural critique
The conflict is personal, but the antagonists—an all-male breed of space pirates who subjugate young girls—function as an allegorical critique of patriarchal structures, although they do not target specific real-world Western institutions.
22%
Woke character or canon changes
Dramatically alters both DC canon and the source material's moral message. The film invents the sex-trafficking subplot and completely flips the comic's ending: rather than guiding Ruthye away from vengeance and sparing the villain, Supergirl brutally stabs and executes Krem herself, a severe departure from traditional heroic ethics.
31%
Anti-woke backlash and complaints
Generated intense backlash from right-leaning and anti-woke audiences who condemned the "depressing" portrayal of a female lead, the "bizarre" and shoehorned sex-trafficking storyline, and Alcock's public comments claiming physical superiority over Superman and inviting queer interpretations.
72%
Creator track record context
Director Craig Gillespie has a history of cynical, female-led antihero projects (e.g., I, Tonya, Cruella). Screenwriter Ana Nogueira's admitted misreading of the comic's ending and producer James Gunn's insistence on changes directly drove the controversial narrative shift.
35%
Production
Movie · 2017
Fuelled by his restored faith in humanity and inspired by Superman's selfless act, Bruce Wayne and Diana Prince assemble a team of metahumans consisting of Barry Allen, Arthur…
Movie · 2023
When his attempt to save his family inadvertently alters the future, Barry Allen becomes trapped in a reality in which General Zod has returned and there are no Super Heroes to…
Movie · 2023
Until now, the Justice League has been a loose association of superpowered individuals. But when they are swept away to Warworld, a place of unending brutal gladiatorial combat…
Movie · 2017
The Guardians must fight to keep their newfound family together as they unravel the mysteries of Peter Quill's true parentage.
Movie · 2016
Following the events of Age of Ultron, the collective governments of the world pass an act designed to regulate all superhuman activity.
Movie · 2022
A mysterious force knocks the moon from its orbit around Earth and sends it hurtling on a collision course with life as we know it.
Movie · 2024
Several generations following Caesar's reign, apes – now the dominant species – live harmoniously while humans have been reduced to living in the shadows.
Movie · 2019
When Alita awakens with no memory of who she is in a future world she does not recognize, she is taken in by Ido, a compassionate doctor who realizes that somewhere in this…
