Movie review
September 23, 2022 · 108 min · PG-13
Woke Score
Lower is better
Review
Catherine Called Birdy is a 2022 medieval comedy in which a 14-year-old girl in 1290 England uses pranks and schemes to repel the suitors her debt-ridden father tries to marry her off to. The film, written and directed by Lena Dunham and adapted from Karen Cushman’s 1994 YA novel, follows Birdy’s coming-of-age rebellion against arranged marriage and traditional female duties. It centers recurring feminist messaging through explicit dialogue, bodily autonomy beats, and a sustained girl-power arc that frames patriarchal control as an oppressive trap to be outwitted by female cleverness.
Breakdown
These are the editorial factors and ratings behind our score for Catherine Called Birdy.
Woke representation / casting
Colorblind casting inserts Black actresses into English noble and widow roles in a 1290 medieval English world, creating visible modern diversity that stands out as an anachronistic production choice even if secondary to the plot.
Woke political dialogue
A gratuitous central speech has Birdy explicitly assert that women “are people” and not commodities to be priced or controlled by men, accompanied by other anachronistic consent and autonomy lines that read as inserted contemporary activist phrasing.
Identity-driven story themes
The entire narrative engine is a teenage girl’s clever, sustained rebellion against arranged marriage and traditional female expectations, repeatedly framing female wit, bodily knowledge, and agency as superior to male authority and patriarchal traps in classic empowerment style.
Western institutional / cultural critique
The film critiques feudal patriarchy and debt-driven arranged marriages as systems that treat daughters as property, portraying traditional gender roles and paternal control as inherently unjust and limiting through a modern feminist lens.
Woke character or canon changes
Minor anachronisms and updated dialogue tone were added to the 1994 source novel, but no major race or gender swaps of iconic characters or plot reversals occurred that drew public debate.
Anti-woke backlash and complaints
Virtually no measurable backlash treating the film as pushing woke, activist, or identity-political content; coverage stayed positive with only scattered notes on heavy-handedness, rendering any anti-woke reaction fringe or nonexistent.
Creator track record context
Lena Dunham’s career shows a consistent pattern of centering feminist critique, female bodily autonomy, and resistance to patriarchal norms across *Girls* and her writing; this project fits that established voice directly.
Production
